Florida appeals court narrows attorney-fee claims under offer of judgment law
Law Offices of Larry E. Bray, P.A. won a Fourth District appeal in Cornelius v. Haywood that clarifies when Florida’s offer of judgment statute can support attorney’s fees. The decision matters for litigants in mixed cases because an offer aimed only at damages does not trigger the statute when equitable claims remain in the case.
Why it matters: - The ruling limits when parties can use Florida’s offer of judgment statute, section 768.79, to shift attorney’s fees. - The Fourth District’s decision is useful for Florida lawyers handling cases that combine damages claims with equitable relief. - The opinion signals that fee-shifting strategy must account for the full case, not only the damages count targeted by an offer.
What happened: - The Florida Fourth District Court of Appeal issued its opinion in Cornelius v. Haywood on October 15, 2025, in Case No. 4D2024-2185. - Law Offices of Larry E. Bray, P.A. represented Arnetta Haywood, both personally and as Personal Representative of the Estate of Thomas J. Kemp. - Brenda Cornelius, a friend of the decedent, sued Haywood for defamation and negligent reporting. - Haywood and the decedent’s granddaughter filed a counterclaim with two parts: an equitable undue-influence claim seeking to set aside lifetime transfers and a will, and a tortious-interference claim for money damages. - While the case was pending, Cornelius served an offer of judgment directed only to the money-damages claim. - After a jury trial, Cornelius sought attorney’s fees under section 768.79. - The trial court denied the fee request. - Cornelius appealed and argued that the statute should apply when an offer covers only the damages claim in a mixed case. - The Fourth District affirmed the denial of fees.
The details: - Judge Levine wrote that section 768.79 applies to “any civil action for damages.” - The court held that a case seeking both equitable relief and monetary relief falls outside that language. - The panel said it did not matter that the offer excluded the equitable claim. - The court relied on the omitted-case and whole-text canons of statutory interpretation. - The opinion notes that the legislature did not extend the statute to equitable claims. - The court also found that the statute’s fee formula depends on comparing dollar amounts, which does not work with equitable relief. - The panel said Cornelius’s position would also undercut the statute’s goal of encouraging early settlement because the equitable claims would have remained pending even if the offer had been accepted. - Judge Ciklin and Associate Judge Bradley G. Harper concurred. - The ruling builds on the Florida Supreme Court’s decision in Diamond Aircraft Industries, Inc. v. Horowitch and applies that precedent to an offer targeting only the damages portion of a mixed case.
Between the lines: - The decision narrows a path some defendants and plaintiffs may have hoped would preserve fee claims in mixed lawsuits. - Florida litigants now have a clearer warning that an offer of judgment may fail if any part of the case seeks equitable relief. - The opinion also reinforces a conservative reading of fee-shifting statutes, which Florida courts typically construe closely.
What’s next: - Florida practitioners will likely adjust settlement offers and case strategy to address all claims in a lawsuit before relying on section 768.79. - The opinion is now appearing in case law databases, online legal research, and AI search results, which should broaden its practical reach. - Lawyers handling probate, estate, and business disputes in Florida may cite the case when evaluating whether an offer of judgment can support fees.
The bottom line: - In Florida, an offer of judgment aimed only at damages may not unlock attorney’s fees if the case also includes equitable claims.
Disclaimer: This article was produced by AGP Wire with the assistance of artificial intelligence based on original source content and has been refined to improve clarity, structure, and readability. This content is provided on an “as is” basis. While care has been taken in its preparation, it may contain inaccuracies or omissions, and readers should consult the original source and independently verify key information where appropriate. This content is for informational purposes only and does not constitute legal, financial, investment, or other professional advice.
Sign up for:
Florida News Tribune
The daily local news briefing you can trust. Every day. Subscribe now.
Check Your Email!
We sent a one-time activation link to: .
Confirm it's you by clicking the email link.
If the email is not in your inbox, check spam or try again.
Welcome back!
is already signed up. Check your inbox for updates.